Comparisons

Flood resilience condition or Flood Re cover

7 min readBy PlanScope Editorial Team

Flood resilient construction secured by a planning condition and the Flood Re reinsurance scheme are often confused. One limits the damage, the other limits the premium, and a new build in a flood zone usually gets only the first.

Flood resilient construction condition and Flood Re cover sound like two routes to the same reassurance. They are not related at all. A planning condition requiring flood resistant and resilient construction is about the building: what happens to the plaster, the floor and the wiring when water arrives. Flood Re is a reinsurance arrangement that sits behind household insurers and keeps premiums for flood risk properties affordable. And Flood Re excludes homes built on or after 1 January 2009, which means a new dwelling in Flood Zone 2 or 3 gets the condition and not the scheme.

That cut-off is deliberate. It exists so the scheme does not subsidise new building in places that flood.

What a resilience condition requires

On a site where flood risk is a live consideration, a permission commonly carries two separate conditions. One fixes the finished floor level above the design flood level, usually with freeboard of 300 mm or more. The other requires a scheme of flood resistant and resilient construction to be submitted and approved, typically before works above damp proof course level, and implemented before occupation.

The resilience condition is discharged by a short document. What a good submission contains:

  1. The design flood level and the finished floor level, with the source of each.
  2. The resistance measures proposed, with their positions and the levels they protect to.
  3. The resilience measures proposed, floor by floor and element by element.
  4. The standards followed, normally BS 85500 and the CIRIA code of practice for property flood resilience.
  5. A drawing marking each measure, rather than a list in prose.
  6. The maintenance and operation arrangements for anything that has to be deployed by the occupier.

Authorities discharge these quickly when the document is specific and slowly when it says that resilient construction will be used in accordance with good practice. The condition is one of the easier ones to get right, and one of the more common ones to be left outstanding at completion because nobody was given the job.

Resistance against resilience

Worth separating properly, because the design responses are different and a scheme usually needs both.

Approach What it does Typical measures
Resistance Keeps water out of the building Demountable door barriers, airbrick covers, non-return valves on foul and surface water drainage, sealed service entries, water-resistant external wall construction
Resilience Limits damage and speeds reinstatement Solid concrete floors with tiled finishes, lime or water-resistant plaster or plasterboard above the risk level, closed-cell insulation, raised sockets and consumer unit, kitchen units on legs, removable skirtings

Resistance has a practical limit. Water under pressure finds routes through walls and up through floors, and holding it out beyond a certain depth risks structural damage. Guidance generally treats resistance as appropriate up to a modest depth and resilience as the answer beyond it, which is why the two sit together rather than as alternatives.

The measures that get forgotten are the services. A consumer unit at skirting level and sockets at 300 mm turn a survivable flood into a rewire. Raising them is one of the least costly decisions on the list and one of the most valuable.

Finished floor levels and freeboard

The floor level is the first line of defence and the one planning cares about most, because it is what makes the development safe for its lifetime.

The design flood level comes from the flood risk assessment, usually from modelled levels for the relevant return period with the appropriate climate change allowance applied. Freeboard is then added on top as a margin for modelling uncertainty. A Flood Risk Assessment should state the design level, the allowance used and the resulting floor level explicitly, because the condition will be drafted from those numbers.

Where the site cannot be raised, because of access gradients, the relationship with neighbouring properties or a conservation constraint on the street scene, the resilience measures carry more of the load and the residual risk discussion in the assessment becomes the important part.

Surface water matters as much as the river. A property raised above a river level can still flood from a blocked highway drain or an overwhelmed sewer, which is why a Drainage Strategy with non-return provision and an exceedance route is part of the same conversation.

What Flood Re does

Flood Re is a reinsurance scheme established under legislation following the Water Act 2014. Household insurers cede the flood element of eligible policies to it at a capped price, which lets them offer cover in high risk areas at premiums customers can pay. It is time-limited by design, with a planned end point, and the intention is that the market adjusts over the scheme's life.

Eligibility is the part that matters here. Residential properties insured in the name of the householder, built before 1 January 2009. New build is out. Most commercial property is out. The scheme also operates an arrangement allowing participating insurers to offer an additional sum towards resilient repair after a claim, so a flooded home is reinstated to a better standard rather than put back exactly as it was. The amount and the terms sit with the scheme and have changed since launch, so check the current position rather than relying on a figure.

For a householder, the practical consequences are two. If you are buying an older house in a flood risk area, Flood Re is probably why the premium is payable. If you are building a new one, it is not available to you, and the quality of your resilience measures and your documentation is what the insurer will price against.

Evidence for discharge, and what to keep

Keep the discharge paperwork. All of it.

The approved resilience scheme, the discharge decision notice, the as-built drawing marking the measures, the product data sheets for barriers and valves, the commissioning records, and photographs taken during construction showing the plaster line, the insulation and the socket heights. That bundle does three jobs: it proves the condition was discharged, it gives an insurer something concrete to price, and it answers the enquiry a buyer's solicitor will raise.

Conditions bind the land and run with it, which is why this matters to the next owner as much as to you. The mechanism is different from a private arrangement between parties, and the distinction between how a condition differs from a covenant is worth understanding if you are buying a property where somebody has promised that measures were installed.

Note: an unimplemented resilience condition on a completed house is a breach, and it is the kind that surfaces at sale rather than during construction.

Insurance consequences of a new build in a flood zone

Be realistic with the client at design stage rather than at handover.

A new dwelling in Flood Zone 3 will be insurable, in most cases, on the open market. The premium and the flood excess will reflect the risk, the floor level, the measures installed and the recorded flood history of the street. Some insurers will decline, and a broker specialising in flood risk is usually needed. Lenders ask about insurability, so the question can affect a mortgage offer rather than only the running cost.

Three things improve the position materially. A floor level comfortably above the design level rather than at the minimum. Documented resilience measures to a recognised standard. And a sequential approach that is visible in the application, because an assessment showing the site was tested against the sequential and exception tests is evidence that the risk was taken seriously.

Before you commission anything, it is worth scoping the reports a site in a flood zone attracts against the mapped constraints, since flood risk rarely travels alone.

This is general guidance, not legal advice, and it is not insurance advice; check the position with your local planning authority, your insurer or a qualified professional before relying on it. PlanScope provides AI-assisted draft reports for planning applications. Reports should be reviewed before submission. We do not guarantee planning approval.

Frequently asked questions

Does Flood Re cover a newly built house?

No. Flood Re does not cover homes built on or after 1 January 2009, a cut-off set deliberately so the scheme does not subsidise building in flood risk areas. A new dwelling in Flood Zone 2 or 3 therefore has to find cover on the open market, which is where resilient construction and good flood documentation matter.

What is the difference between resistance and resilience?

Resistance keeps water out, using barriers, airbrick covers, non-return valves on drainage and sealed external walls. Resilience accepts that water may enter and limits the damage, using solid floors, water-resistant plaster or lime render, raised electrical sockets, closed-cell insulation and removable fittings. Most schemes use both together.

What does a resilience condition actually require?

Typically that a scheme of flood resistant and resilient construction is submitted and approved before works above damp proof course level, and implemented before occupation. The submitted scheme should name the measures, the levels they apply to and the standards followed, usually BS 85500 and the CIRIA code of practice for property flood resilience.

Will a condition get my finished floor level raised?

A floor level condition is usually separate from the resilience condition. It sets a level above the design flood level, commonly with 300 mm of freeboard or more. Both conditions can appear on the same permission, and the resilience measures are then designed for the residual risk that remains above that level.

Does Flood Re pay for resilient repairs?

Flood Re operates a scheme allowing participating insurers to offer an additional sum towards resilient repair after a flood claim, so damage is repaired to a better standard rather than put back as it was. The amount and the terms are set by the scheme and have changed since launch, so check the current position with the insurer.

What should I ask before buying a house in a flood zone?

Whether the property was built before 1 January 2009, what the recorded flood history is, whether any resilience measures were installed and whether they were a condition of permission, what the current insurer charges and what excess applies, and whether the finished floor level sits above the modelled design flood level for the site.

Sources and further reading

flood riskflood reresilient constructionplanning conditionsinsurancehouseholder

This article is general guidance about the planning system in England and, where stated, the rest of the UK. It is not legal or professional advice. Check your local planning authority’s validation requirements and take professional advice for your specific site.

More in Comparisons

View all →
Comparisons6 min read

Extension of time agreement or renewing a permission

Two things that get confused. Extending the determination period is routine; extending the life of a permission is impossible, and section 73 cannot do it either.

Read article →
Comparisons7 min read

Deed of variation or a section 106A application

Two routes to change a planning obligation, with very different tests. Why section 106A is not a viability hearing, and when a fresh application beats both.

Read article →
Comparisons7 min read

Building notice or full plans application to building control

Two routes to building control approval under the Building Regulations 2010. What each involves, where a building notice is unavailable, and how completion certificates and regularisation work.

Read article →
Comparisons8 min read

Dropped kerb approval or permission for a front hardstanding

The crossover is licensed under the Highways Act 1980. The driveway behind it is permitted development only if it is porous or drains inside your boundary. Most people need both approvals.

Read article →
Comparisons7 min read

Strategic Environmental Assessment or Sustainability Appraisal

A local plan appraisal discharges two duties at once: strategic environmental assessment under the 2004 Regulations and sustainability appraisal under section 19(5). Only one has sharp legal teeth.

Read article →
Comparisons7 min read

Environmental permit or planning permission for a waste use

The Environment Agency permits the operation. The waste planning authority decides whether the use belongs there. Both are needed, and a registered exemption is not a planning permission.

Read article →