Use Classes and Change of Use

Ancillary use and the planning unit explained

7 min readBy PlanScope Editorial Team

Materiality under section 55 is judged against the planning unit, so identifying the unit comes before any use class analysis. The Burdle test still does the work.

Before you can decide which use class a site falls into, you have to decide what the site is. The planning unit is the parcel of land in a single occupation for a single main purpose, and it is the frame within which every question about material change of use is answered. Get the unit wrong and the class analysis that follows is worthless, however carefully it is argued.

The orthodox test comes from Burdle, where the court set out three situations: a unit occupied for a single main purpose with other activities ancillary to it, a composite unit where two or more activities exist without one being incidental to another, and physically separate areas in the same occupation used for substantially different and unrelated purposes, which form separate units. Those three descriptions still do most of the work in practice.

Why the unit comes before the class

Section 55 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 makes a material change in the use of any buildings or other land development. The change has to be material, and materiality is judged against the use of the planning unit as a whole, not against one room or one activity.

That has a direct consequence. An activity that would be a separate use if it stood alone may be no more than an ancillary part of a larger unit, in which case starting it is not development at all. A print room in an office, a staff canteen in a factory, a small shop inside a hospital: none of those create a change of use while they remain subordinate to the main purpose and serve it.

The same logic cuts the other way when an authority wants to allege a breach. If the enforcement officer treats one unit of a larger site as the planning unit, the alleged change looks material. If the whole site is the unit, the same activity may be lost in the mix. Arguing about the unit is frequently the substance of the case.

The occupation test, applied

Start with occupation, because the unit cannot be larger than the area in one occupation. Two separately let shops in one building are two units however similar their trade. A single tenancy over two floors is one unit even where the floors are used differently.

Then look at purpose. Where everything on the site serves one main purpose, you have one unit. Where two activities coexist and neither is subordinate, you have a composite unit with a mixed use, and the lawful use is the mix rather than either component.

Then look at physical and functional separation. Separate access, separate services, separate staff, separate hours and a physical division all point towards separate units. Shared facilities, shared management and interdependent operation point back towards one.

The test is applied on the facts as they are. Planning history describes what was permitted, which is a different thing. A site may carry a permission for one thing and have become, lawfully or otherwise, something else.

Ancillary, incidental and mixed

The vocabulary matters here because the terms are not interchangeable.

Term Where it bites Practical meaning
Ancillary Any planning unit An activity subordinate to and serving the main use, carrying no separate class of its own
Incidental Dwellinghouses, through section 55(2)(d) and Part 1 of the GPDO A use incidental to the enjoyment of the dwellinghouse as such, judged objectively as well as by the occupier's wishes
Composite or mixed Any planning unit Two or more activities, none subordinate, so the lawful use is the mix

A home office used by the resident is ordinarily incidental. The same room used by three employees who arrive by van each morning is not, because the character of the use has changed and the residential purpose is no longer the whole story. Nothing in the floor area decides that question by itself.

Mixed uses are often undersold in applications. Where the lawful use is in fact a mix, say so, because a mixed use carries flexibility within its components that a single class does not, and losing it by describing the site as a single class is a real cost. Our note on co-living schemes and what use class they fall into looks at the same problem where the operational model straddles two classes.

When an ancillary activity becomes a primary use

There is no percentage that converts an ancillary activity into a separate use. The question is whether the activity has acquired a character of its own and ceased to be subordinate, and the indicators councils and inspectors look at are consistent:

  • Independent trading to the public rather than to the occupiers of the main use
  • Separate entrance, separate signage, separate opening hours
  • A floor area and staffing level out of proportion to the main use
  • Separate rating assessment or separate letting
  • Advertising and online presence marketing it as a business in its own right
  • Deliveries, servicing and waste streams that exist only for that activity

A tea room in a garden centre that opens after the centre closes, takes bookings and is advertised independently has probably become a separate use. The same tea room serving customers mid-visit has not.

Sports and social clubs make a good illustration of how finely this is sliced, and our note on sports and social clubs: Class F2 or sui generis works through the bar-to-sport balance that decides those cases.

Subdivision and intensification

Subdivision is the clearest statutory rule in this area. Under section 55(3)(a), the use as two or more separate dwellinghouses of a building previously used as a single dwellinghouse involves a material change of use, so splitting a house into flats always needs permission. The reasoning is that subdivision creates new planning units.

Subdividing commercial floorspace is not covered by that provision and is judged on ordinary principles. Splitting one large retail unit into three smaller ones within the same class is often held not to be material, but where the subdivision changes the character of the frontage, the servicing pattern or the trading nature of the parade, materiality becomes arguable.

Intensification is harder. More of the same use is not development merely because there is more of it. It becomes a material change only where the increase alters the character of the use, which is why intensification arguments succeed on things like a house in multiple occupation taking more occupiers than its class allows, and usually fail on a shop that gets busier.

Evidence for the extent of a unit

A planning unit is a question of fact, so it is proved with records rather than assertion. The material that carries weight:

  1. Title and tenancy documents showing the extent of each occupation and the dates.
  2. Rating list entries, which follow occupation and often reveal how the site has been treated historically.
  3. Dated floor plans showing internal divisions, access points and which areas were connected.
  4. Staffing records, rotas and payroll showing who worked where.
  5. Utility accounts and meter arrangements.
  6. Trading records showing the split of turnover between activities.
  7. Aerial and street level imagery with dates, for physical separation.
  8. Statutory declarations from people with first hand knowledge, where documents are missing.

Where the unit matters to lawfulness rather than to a new application, a certificate under section 191 or 192 of the 1990 Act is the way to fix it, and the burden of proof sits with the applicant on the balance of probabilities.

Describing the unit on the application

Two mistakes recur. The first is a red line drawn around less than the planning unit, which invites the authority to assess the proposal against a unit that does not exist and can undermine the permission later. The second is a description of existing use taken from the last permission rather than from the facts on the ground.

Describe the existing lawful use of the unit, identify the unit on the site plan, and if the lawful use is a mix, set out the components and the evidence for each. Then explain the proposed use in the same terms. A planning statement that spends a page establishing the unit before touching policy is doing the most useful thing it can do, because everything downstream depends on it. The same discipline matters on prior approval applications, where the qualifying conditions are tested against the building and its lawful use, as our note on Class MA: the three month vacancy rule no longer applies sets out.

PlanScope drafts a planning statement with the existing use and planning unit stated explicitly and flags the facts it cannot verify rather than filling them in. Drafts should be reviewed before submission, and PlanScope does not guarantee planning approval.

This is general guidance, not legal advice. Check the position with your local planning authority or a qualified professional before relying on it. A lawful development certificate is the only formal way to confirm that an existing use is lawful.

Frequently asked questions

What is a planning unit?

It is the parcel of land in a single occupation used for a single main purpose, against which materiality of any change of use is judged. The Burdle approach identifies three cases: one main purpose with ancillary activities, a composite unit where no activity is subordinate, and physically separate areas in one occupation used for unrelated purposes, which form separate units.

What is the difference between ancillary and incidental?

Ancillary describes an activity subordinate to and serving the main use of any planning unit, carrying no class of its own. Incidental is the statutory language used for dwellinghouses in section 55(2)(d) and Part 1 of the GPDO, covering a use incidental to the enjoyment of the dwellinghouse, which is judged objectively rather than purely by the occupier's preference.

Does splitting a house into flats need planning permission?

Yes. Section 55(3)(a) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 provides that using a building previously occupied as a single dwellinghouse as two or more separate dwellinghouses involves a material change of use. Subdivision creates new planning units, so the rule applies regardless of whether any building work is carried out.

Can intensification of an existing use need permission?

Only where the increase changes the character of the use rather than simply its volume. More of the same activity is not development by itself. Arguments succeed where the character shifts, for instance where occupancy moves a dwelling out of its class, and usually fail where a shop or office merely becomes busier within the same class.

How do you prove the extent of a planning unit?

With records rather than assertion: tenancy and title documents, rating list entries, dated floor plans showing internal connections, staffing rotas, utility and metering arrangements, turnover splits, and dated imagery for physical separation. Where lawfulness is the issue, a certificate under section 191 or 192 fixes the position on the balance of probabilities.

Sources and further reading

planning unituse classeschange of usesection 55ancillary use

This article is general guidance about the planning system in England and, where stated, the rest of the UK. It is not legal or professional advice. Check your local planning authority’s validation requirements and take professional advice for your specific site.

More in Use Classes and Change of Use

View all →
Use Classes and Change of Use7 min read

House to small HMO: the C3 to C4 change explained

The C3 to C4 change is permitted development until an Article 4 direction or a seventh occupant removes it. Here is what each situation requires.

Read article →
Use Classes and Change of Use7 min read

Use Classes Order 2020: what changed and what it saved

The 2020 amendment created Class E and pushed pubs and takeaways into sui generis, but it preserved the revoked class definitions for interpreting earlier permissions, conditions and Article 4 directions.

Read article →
Use Classes and Change of Use7 min read

Changing part of a building and the subdivision trap

Why dividing one planning unit into two can need permission, what physical evidence points to two units, and the severance conditions hiding in old permissions.

Read article →
Use Classes and Change of Use6 min read

Mixed use: when one permission covers two activities

Why a mixed use sits outside the Use Classes Order, how to draft the description of development, and what it costs you in later flexibility.

Read article →
Use Classes and Change of Use6 min read

Retrospective change of use and the certificate route

How a certificate of lawful existing use differs from a retrospective planning application, what evidence proves a use on the balance of probability, and the sequencing that keeps both routes open.

Read article →
Use Classes and Change of Use7 min read

Converting a pub: the consents a sui generis use needs

A drinking establishment is sui generis, so any change of use or demolition needs planning permission. Marketing evidence is where most applications fail.

Read article →