Mixed use: when one permission covers two activities
Why a mixed use sits outside the Use Classes Order, how to draft the description of development, and what it costs you in later flexibility.
A mixed use planning permission sits outside the Use Classes Order altogether. That is the point most people miss. The Order lists classes, and article 3 of it provides that a change of use within a class is not development, but a planning unit used for two or more primary purposes is in none of the classes, so none of that flexibility applies to it. Permit a building as a mixed use of Class E and residential, and every later change to the balance of those uses is potentially a material change of use needing its own permission.
That trade, flexibility on day one for rigidity afterwards, is the thing to explain to a client before the application is drafted.
How a mixed use is described on the application
The description of development is the permission. Draft it as though it will be read in ten years by someone with no knowledge of the scheme, because it will be.
A workable description names the uses, says where each sits, and avoids numbers it cannot support. "Change of use of ground floor to mixed use comprising retail (Class E(a)) and hot food takeaway (sui generis)" is clear. "Mixed commercial use" is not, and will either be refused as imprecise or granted in terms so wide that the council later regrets it and the owner later relies on it.
Three drafting decisions carry consequences:
- whether the uses are described by class reference or by activity
- whether floor areas or proportions appear in the description
- whether the whole planning unit is covered, or only part of a building
Put floor areas on the plans rather than in the description where you can. A description that fixes 120 square metres of retail becomes a problem when a partition moves by a metre.
Why a mixed use is not a class
Section 55 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 treats a material change in the use of a building or land as development. The Order then removes certain changes from that definition, either because they fall within a single class or because they are expressly permitted between classes.
A mixed use planning unit cannot benefit from either mechanism. There is no class to move within, and the Part 3 permitted development classes almost all require the existing use to fall within a specified class. Class MA, for instance, requires use within Class E, so a building in mixed Class E and residential use does not qualify.
| Position | Flexibility available |
|---|---|
| Single use within Class E | Movement between E(a) to E(g) is not development, and Part 3 classes may apply |
| Single sui generis use | No internal flexibility, some Part 3 rights by specific class |
| Mixed use of two or more primary purposes | No class flexibility, Part 3 rights generally unavailable |
| Single use with an ancillary activity | Treated as the primary use, ancillary activity follows it |
The last row is the one to reach for first. If one activity is ancillary to another, there is a single use rather than a mixed one, and the flexibility of the class survives. A staff canteen in an office is ancillary. A cafe open to the public from the same building is a second primary use.
Identifying the planning unit
The planning unit is the unit of occupation, and the approach from Burdle remains the working test. Where one occupier uses the whole of a site for one main purpose with ancillary activities, the unit is the whole site. Where there are two or more primary activities, there is a single unit in mixed use. Where physically separate areas are used for substantially different and unrelated purposes, each is its own unit.
Get this wrong and the rest of the analysis collapses. A first-floor flat over a shop in separate occupation is a separate planning unit, not half of a mixed use, and treating it as a mixed use understates what has happened to the building.
Proportions between the uses and whether they bind
Unless a condition says otherwise, a mixed use permission does not fix the proportions. The use is the mixture, and shifting the balance within it may or may not be material depending on the degree of change and its planning consequences.
Intensifying one element to the point where the character of the use changes is a material change, and that is a question of fact and degree rather than percentage. Doubling the takeaway element of a mixed retail and takeaway unit, with the extraction, deliveries and late hours that follow, will be material. Moving a shelf will not.
Councils that care about the balance use conditions. Typical wording restricts the floor area given to one use by reference to an approved plan, limits hours for one element, or requires the retained element to remain in use. Those conditions are the real control, and they are also the thing to negotiate hardest at the drafting stage, because a condition fixing floor areas to a drawing turns an internal fit-out into a planning application.
Later changes within a mixed use
Three routes exist when a mixed use needs to change.
- A section 73 application to vary a condition, where a condition is what constrains you.
- A fresh application for a different mixed use, or for a single use, where the mixture itself is changing.
- A section 96A non-material amendment, which only works for minor changes and cannot alter the description of development.
A fourth is worth mentioning because clients ask for it: a certificate of lawful proposed use under section 192, confirming that a proposed change would not be development. That is useful where you think the change is immaterial and want certainty before spending money, and it is decided on fact and law rather than merits.
Evidence on an application for mixed use
A mixed use application attracts more scrutiny than its floor area suggests, because the council is assessing two sets of impacts at once.
- floor plans with each use coloured and areas scheduled
- an operational description for each element: hours, staff, deliveries, waste
- a Transport Statement where trip generation differs between the uses
- a ventilation and extraction statement where any food preparation is involved
- a noise assessment where plant serves one use and dwellings occupy another part of the building
- a Planning Statement setting out why the mixture is acceptable in policy terms and how the uses coexist
The coexistence argument is the one officers test. A mixed use with residential above a commercial element has to address the agent of change principle: the commercial use was there first, so the residential element carries the mitigation. Glazing, ventilation, layout and plant isolation, specified rather than promised.
Rating, valuation and the practical consequences
Expect the valuation officer to treat the elements separately where they are capable of separate occupation, which affects business rates and council tax. Community Infrastructure Levy liability also turns on the mix, since rates are usually set by use and the offset for existing floorspace depends on whether the building has been in lawful use for the qualifying period.
Lenders ask about it too. A mixed use unit can be harder to value and to lend against than two separate units, which is an argument for considering subdivision into separate planning units instead, where the physical arrangement allows it.
For buildings where the use question is unsettled, our pieces on co-living schemes and their use class and film and television studios show how often the classification argument precedes the planning one.
Enter your postcode on PlanScope to see which documents a mixed use application on your building would need.
This is general guidance, not legal advice; check the position with your local planning authority or a qualified professional before relying on it. PlanScope provides AI-assisted draft reports for planning applications. Reports should be reviewed before submission. We do not guarantee planning approval.
Frequently asked questions
Is mixed use a use class?
No. The Use Classes Order lists classes, and a planning unit used for two or more primary purposes falls within none of them. That means the rule treating a change within a class as not amounting to development does not help, and most Part 3 permitted development classes, which require the existing use to fall in a specified class, are unavailable.
How should a mixed use be described on the application form?
Name each use, by class reference or by activity, and say where each sits in the building. Avoid vague wording such as mixed commercial use, which is either refused as imprecise or granted so widely that it causes trouble later. Keep floor areas on the approved plans rather than in the description where possible.
Do the proportions between the uses bind the owner?
Only if a condition says so. Without a condition, the permitted use is the mixture, and changing the balance is development only where the change is material. Intensifying one element until the character of the use changes will be material, so councils that care about the balance impose conditions tied to an approved plan or to hours.
Can I use Class MA on a mixed use building?
No, not while the use is mixed. Class MA requires the building to have been in use falling within Class E, and a mixed use is not within Class E even where one element of it would be. The same logic defeats most Part 3 classes, which is one of the practical costs of a mixed use permission.
What is the difference between a mixed use and an ancillary use?
An ancillary activity serves the primary use and is treated as part of it, so the planning unit remains in the primary use and keeps its class flexibility. A second primary use creates a mixed use. A staff canteen in an office is ancillary, while a café in the same building open to the public is a second primary use.
How do I change a mixed use later?
By a section 73 application if a condition is the constraint, by a fresh application if the mixture itself is changing, or by a section 96A amendment for minor changes that leave the description intact. Where you believe a change is immaterial, a certificate of lawful proposed use gives certainty on fact and law before you spend money.
Sources and further reading
This article is general guidance about the planning system in England and, where stated, the rest of the UK. It is not legal or professional advice. Check your local planning authority’s validation requirements and take professional advice for your specific site.